Providing good support for “good people”
How the attitudes of police recruits change during their first year of training – and where training could step in to preserve trust
To the point:
- Loss of trust: Police students start with positive attitudes but lose a significant amount of trust in society during their first year of training.
- Impact of police work: Stress, hierarchy, and confrontational situations can negatively affect recruits’ personalities and undermine prosocial values.
- Training potential: There is a need for training programs that help sustain officers’ trust, prosocial motivations, and empathy despite occupational stress.
A research study by the Max Planck Institute for the Study of Crime, Security and Law sheds new light on the start of a policing career: recruits begin their studies with positive attitudes but, as early as within the first year, become less trusting of others and more inclined toward hierarchical societal ideals. These changes emerge especially after the initial “reality shock” of field training.
In this longitudinal study, the team led by Max Planck researcher Hannes Rusch surveyed approx. 130 students at a German police university three times during their first year: at the start of training, after six months of classroom instruction, and after the first on-the-street placement. The measures captured personality, social attitudes, and attitudes toward the police. Social dominance orientation (SDO) – a measure of preferences for social hierarchies – was also assessed.
Additionally, there were two comparison groups: to better contextualize possible attitude changes during the first year of study, approximately 100 students from various disciplines at a Dutch university were surveyed in parallel. In addition, the team compared the police data with those from a reference sample of over 4,500 participants from the German general population.
How attitudes change
- Police students begin their training with prosocial, humanistic views. In particular, they score significantly higher than the population sample on honesty, modesty, and social openness. Over the first year, however, these traits decline markedly and converge toward population levels.
- These changes appear only among police students; among the comparison students – whose scores are lower to start with – attitudes remain stable. This suggests the shifts are not mere effects of time at university or age, but are triggered by features specific to police training and work.
- Police university students show substantially higher SDO than the German general population sample at the outset, and SDO increases further during the first year – indicating a growing preference for hierarchical social order. By contrast, no such increase is observed among the non-police university students in the comparison group.
“Our study suggests that police officers begin to lose trust in society as early as during training, and their positive values partly shift,” summarizes Max Planck psychologist Julia Teufel. This could negatively impact the quality of police work.
Approaches to Police Training
“The combination of stress, hierarchy, and confrontational encounters officers face may impact personality. What we see is a trajectory that can undermine prosociality – a warning sign for the future of policing,” adds Hannes Rusch, a research group leader at the Max Planck Institute for the Study of Crime, Security and Law whose work includes research on policing.
Teufel and Rusch both see untapped potential in police training: “We can see that many ‘good people’ join the police. We need training programs that help them preserve human values such as trust, prosocial motivation, and empathy, even in the face of job-related stress and frustration.”












